Check the AI answer before you act.
A fluent answer can feel finished before you have checked its claims. Use this checklist to turn a convincing draft into something you can evaluate.
Start with the claim that matters
Separate the answer into recommendations, factual claims, and assumptions. Identify the claim that would most change your decision if it were wrong. Check that first. You do not need to spend the same effort on a stylistic suggestion and a consequential factual assertion.
A practical verification checklist
- Open the source. Does it exist, and does it actually support the claim? A citation’s presence is not the same as verification.
- Check the date. Is the information current enough for your decision? Look at when the event occurred as well as when the page was updated.
- Match the context. Does the answer apply to your location, product version, audience, and constraints?
- Check the working. Recalculate important numbers and inspect the assumptions behind comparisons.
- Look for a challenge. What independent evidence would contradict the recommendation?
- Choose a test. Where possible, try a limited, reversible action before a broad rollout.
Worked example: a website recommendation
An AI answer recommends redirecting an existing page to a new URL. Before implementing it, check whether the old page has search traffic, whether the destination serves the same purpose, and whether internal links and canonical tags will agree with the change.
Ask for the reason behind the recommendation. A cleaner-looking URL alone may not justify a migration. Test the proposed redirect and retain a backup before changing the live site. After deployment, check the actual response and destination rather than relying on a confident completion message.
A prompt you can reuse
Separate the facts, assumptions, and recommendations in this answer. For each decision-critical fact, provide a primary source and its date. Mark what you could not verify. Explain what evidence would change your recommendation.
This prompt organizes the review; it does not independently verify the response. Open important sources yourself and use appropriate expertise where the consequences require it.
What if the answer has no sources?
Treat checkable factual claims as unverified until you find support. You can still use the response to generate questions, outline a draft, or identify alternatives. Avoid turning an unsupported statement into a commitment simply because it is easy to read.
When to stop and seek a better source
If you cannot verify the key claim and the choice is hard to reverse, pause the commitment. Identify an authoritative source or a qualified person who can resolve the gap. When the choice is low impact and reversible, a small test may be a more useful next step than another round of unstructured prompting.
Continue with the right tool
Use Wiry to examine your reaction to the answer, Surer to continue reviewing evidence, and YourArtificial to explore AI. For the underlying decision habit, read confidence versus evidence.